Senior Ministers of Broadway UMC

  • 1873 - 1875: Amos Hanaway 
  • 1875 - 1876: Frost Craft
  • 1876 - 1887: F. S. Potts 
  • 1877 - 1880: J. S. Reager
  • 1880 - 1883: R. D. Black
  • 1883 - 1885: M. L. Wells 
  • 1885 - 1886: F. S. Tincher
  • 1886 - 1889: F. H. Wydman 
  • 1889 - 1892: John S. Tevis 
  • 1892 - 1894: T. W. Northcott
  • 1894 - 1895: George H. Murphy
  • 1895 - 1898: Louis F. Dimmitt
  • 1898 - 1900: V. W. Tevis
  • 1900 - 1901: Charles. William Tinsley
  • 1901- 1905: Worth M. Tippey
  • 1905 - 1909: Layton C. Bentley 
  • 1909 - 1910: Chas. E. Bacon
  • 1910 - 1912: John M. Walker
  • 1912 - 1918: Joseph N. Greene 
  • 1918 - 1923: Wm. B. Farmer
  • 1923 - 1924: C. Howard Taylor 
  • 1924 - 1930: John W. McFall
  • 1930 - 1932: Wm. C. Hartinger
  • 1932 - 1940: Richard M. Millard
  • 1940 - 1946: John F. Edwards
  • 1946 - 1949: Newman S. Jeffrey
  • 1949 - 1957: Robert B. Pierce
  • 1958-1968: A. James Armstrong
  • 1969-1971: Richard C. Thistle
  • 1972-1977: Robert F. Fribley
  • 1977-1986: James F. Morin
  • 1986-1992: Philip Amerson
  • 1992-1995: Mary Ann Moman & Summer Walters (Co-Sr. Pastors) 
  • 1995-1996: Jeff Trees
  • 1996-2003: Franklin D. Sablan
  • 2003-2020: Michael Mather 
  • 2020-Present: R. Aaron Hobbs

Associate Ministers  of Broadway

  • Lloyd Moffett (1927-1929)
  • Maurice Kerr (1929-1929)
  • Elmer Lee Harvey (1937-1939)
  • R. D. Ochiltree (1944-1946)
  • Carl D. Shafer (1949-1954)
  • William R. Brantley (1950-1956)
  • Lester H. Bill (1953-1963)
  • Edward Ellsworth Aldrich (1958-1965)
  • Aubrey Allen Crawford (1958-1960)
  • Charles Martin Blackmon (1963-1966)
  • Everett F. Landrey (1965-1975)
  • Larry M. Curtis (1966-1969)
  • Larry Sanner (1966-1969) 
  • William Oliver Lipp (1967-1969)
  • John F. Willson (1969-1978)
  • Robert H. Stine (1971-1975)
  • James W. Witty (1977-1982)
  • Christy Marshall (1977-1986)
  • Donald Jackson (1977-1986)
  • Floyd Cook (1977-1987)
  • Michael Mather (1986-1991)
  • Mary Ann Moman (1986-1992)
  • Vanessa Allen Brown (1987-1992)
  • Jicelyn Thomas (1987-1993)
  • Everett Woodcock (1987-2001)
  • Suhyoung Baik (1989 - 2011)
  • William A. Taylor III (1995-1996)
  • John Gibson (1996-2003)
  • Gene Critchfield (1996-2003)
  • Rachel Metheny (1999-2017)
  • Duane Carlisle (2018-2020)
  • Alicia Baker (2020-2021)
  • Shonda Nicole Gladden (2022-Current)